Can a landlord deny a request for accommodation based simply on observation of a tenant's ability?

A landlord cannot deny a request for accommodation solely based on the observation of a tenant's ability because such actions violate fair housing laws that protect individuals with disabilities. The Fair Housing Act requires landlords to provide reasonable accommodations to individuals with disabilities when necessary to afford them an equal opportunity to use and enjoy a dwelling. This means that a person’s perceived ability or appearance should not be the basis for denying accommodations.

Assessments regarding a need for accommodation should be based on legitimate documentation of a tenant's disability and their specific needs, rather than superficial observations. In this context, it's important to ensure that all tenants are treated equitably, regardless of their appearance or physical abilities, as assumptions can lead to discrimination against individuals with disabilities who may be capable of living independently but still require certain accommodations to do so effectively.

The other options suggest scenarios where it might be permissible to deny accommodations, but they do not align with the fundamental principles of fair housing, as such actions could lead to discriminatory practices against individuals based on misconceptions or biases.